Are Jehovah's Witnesses a Cult?

Do Jehovah’s Witnesses Cross the Line Into Violating Child Labor Laws Within Their Religion?

child laborHow do you feel when you see pictures like this one on the left? Sickened and disgusted at how children are exploited for heavy, manual labor that is well beyond their physical abilities, working in dirty conditions that are obviously unsafe even for adults?

Do you feel angry at the big businesses that exploit such labor, and who take advantage of children and their poor families in these situations by forcing them to work for slave wages in such conditions?

Do you immediately wish that there was a number you could call to complain about using children in this way, to give the CEO and other officers and owners of this company a good piece of your mind about how they treat children? Are you ready to boycott the company that would use child labor in such conditions, and that would make  a young, sweet, innocent child look so overwhelmed and unhappy?

If so, your attitude is quite different that of Jehovah’s Witnesses; here’s the actual picture as it was sent to me, without my cropping:

10653523_1581874742070841_7034755719382523789_n

Child Participation in the Religion

Children of Jehovah’s Witnesses learn to participate in the religion from a very young age, and certainly there is nothing wrong with some forms of this participation. For example, during their weekly study of the Watchtower magazine, a child might be called on to give a simple answer. When they become old enough, they may read scriptures as part of their comments or give short discourses in front of the congregation.

Participating in church services is not the only thing expected from children of Jehovah’s Witnesses, however. Young children and even babies accompany their parents in the door-to-door preaching work. When they’re young, children may ring the doorbells of the houses or hold a tract that their parents will offer, and as they get older they may read a scripture or give a quick presentation to whomever answers the door. Usually by their preteen years, they’re expected to be giving their own presentations to householders on their own.

Other day-to-day participation in the religion may include helping to clean the Kingdom Hall when assigned, as well as assembly halls and the sports arenas where district conventions are held. I believe that once they’re 16, they can also volunteer to assist at these conventions on their own.

Participation Versus Labor

Participating in church services when you’re a child is certainly not anything new or specific to Jehovah’s Witnesses; Catholics have altar boys, other religions have Sunday schools with youth participation along with youth choirs, volunteer groups, and the like. However, when does participation in church activities cross the line into labor for a corporation, and when does that labor become illegal for a young child?

Think for a moment about the preaching work of Jehovah’s Witnesses and what it entails. When I was “in,” there was a meeting to organize car groups at 9:00 a.m. at the local Kingdom Hall; we would usually be out and knocking on our first door by 9:30. At 12:30, there was another meeting; many participants only worked during this morning segment and would drop off their car group at noon; those who wanted to continue in the preaching would eat their lunch before the 12:30 meeting. By 1:00 p.m. they were back out knocking on doors, and might quit around 3:00 or 3:30 p.m. This arrangement might vary slightly in different areas, but could be considered a good example of a daily preaching schedule.

child labor 2

Participation in church services, or child labor?

For a child being brought into this work, they would be sitting at a Kingdom Hall by 9:00 a.m., and not be done with this work until noon; that’s three hours of walking up and down streets or sitting in the Kingdom Hall or a car, waiting for others. Many children did participate in this work during the week, as children of Jehovah’s Witnesses are often homeschooled and accompany their parents when they go out preaching. Children in public schools often participated in this work every Saturday.

I might pose the question, how is this preaching not considered “employment” or outright labor? It’s not a church service or ritual, it’s not done inside a comfortable, air conditioned church, and it’s sole purpose is to recruit new members of the religion. Those who preach leave literature published by Jehovah’s Witnesses and aim to start “bible studies” so that they can make new converts, or members of the church. Again, how is this not “labor” or actual work, versus simple church participation? If a school took children out into the neighborhood for hours at a time, knocking on doors to find new students, I imagine parents would object to their children being sent out to do this free work for them. Yet, when it’s a religion it’s okay?

Hazardous Conditions

child labor 3

Please be wearing sunscreen… Please be wearing sunscreen… Please be wearing sunscreen…

According to child labor laws, in the U.S. a child under 14 cannot be employed and, if they are over 14, they cannot work for more than 3 hours during a school day; the exceptions are employment by parents, newspaper routes, child actors, and agricultural work. No matter other restrictions, children cannot be employed in hazardous conditions. Very ironically, door-to-door solicitation can be considered hazardous and is prohibited by children under certain ages in many states in the U.S., for a full rundown of those current laws, visit the Department of Labor’s website at this page.

While the door-to-door preaching work of Jehovah’s Witnesses is not considered solicitation because they are not technically selling a product, consider why this type of work in particular is considered “hazardous” and my be prohibited by law in general. For one thing, it is very labor-intensive and involves being outside in all but the very worst weather conditions. Jehovah’s Witnesses take their children out to preach during summer and winter, in the heat, cold, and rain. Householders are often abrupt and rude and even downright verbally abusive, perhaps even screaming and yelling obscenities at the Witnesses at their door; children are subject to this type of abuse when they’re in this work, with little means to contain the behavior of a householder, as there is no Human Resources department or agency at which a child may lodge a complaint for such treatment.

Construction Sites and the Greed of Jehovah’s Witnesses

Heat, cold, and rain may not seem hazardous, but take another look at the photo at the top of this page. A small boy, about four or five, carrying a load of bricks as tall as his torso, without a shirt and I’m guessing without shoes. He’s on a construction site with no hard hat, no safety vest, no eye protection. This picture was used in a website that decried child labor around the world, using it as an example of the abusive and horrific situations in which these children work. Yet, again, this Pinterest user felt that it was “wonderful” for him to be in those conditions.

While the picture above is not from a Kingdom Hall build site, I do remember children working on those types of sites for many years before rules were finally put into place regarding a minimum age for such work (15 in the area in which I live). Note that those children I remember, and the teens who currently volunteer at such sites, are building a new Kingdom Hall for which their own families may have helped pay for, and which will be owned by the leaders of his religion. (See this post for more on the property flipping and other financial schemes of Jehovah’s Witnesses.) While they may not have worked shirtless and barefoot, I’m sure most people would realize that construction work is hard work that even fully grown adults find difficult and physically taxing.

Child Labor = Religion of Love?

11010290_1423106247996544_68723806308600479_n

Sunscreen and now shoes.

I’m sure some might make a legal argument about whether or not the work of Jehovah’s Witnesses, and the participation of their children, can be considered actual child labor, but I’m not trying to make a legal argument here; this is my blog, not a court of law. My point is simply that the children of this religion do an inordinate amount of work to make new recruits, maintain property they don’t own, and work to build new property they won’t ever own in the future. Their comfort and enjoyment, health, physical well-being, and even their safety aren’t always of importance to this religion when it comes to putting them to work to support it and help it grow.

Note, I’m all for having children work and do chores around the house, and no doubt participating in a religion makes them feel like they’re more of a part of it, like participating in school. Chances are children enjoy certain forms of participation, to a certain extent. They may relish giving comments at a Sunday meeting and it’s sometimes cute to see a child dusting chairs at a Kingdom Hall.

We’re not talking about incidental participation like that, however. We’re talking about hours and hours of working to recruit new members for your religion, and pictures of children working in unsafe conditions that would be illegal for a professional contractor, with other Jehovah’s Witnesses referring to this free labor in those conditions as a “wonderful provision” from Jehovah. Legal or not, how is this a loving arrangement or “wonderful,” and a provision from god himself? Loving to whom?

Show Me the Scripture

It’s also worth noting that there is no scriptural precedent for having children working such backbreaking labor, or even preaching for that matter. Jesus chose adult men to be his apostles and to send in the preaching work, and his only interaction with children were when they were playing in the market and then approached him while he was teaching. It’s also worth nothing that Jehovah’s Witnesses often criticize “the world,” or anyone and everyone who is not a JW, and their “lack of love,” as the December, 2006, Awake magazine says:

“The lack of love you see in the world is largely due to its being filled with self-centered people, many of whom were raised in homes without restraint.”

Yet, it’s this same “world” that made child labor laws in the first place, in order to protect children from abuse and exploitation. These laws are far from perfect, but it’s striking that this supposedly loveless “world” has at least attempted to protect children from being used for cheap physical labor, more so than a so-called loving religion that is Jehovah’s Witnesses, which is more than happy to take full advantage of that very same labor.

*** ***

If you would like to voice your complaint over the use of children for religious recruitment and for how congregants feel that children working in construction projects in unsafe conditions is “wonderful,” please visit the Contact Us page of the official website of Jehovah’s Witnesses and choose your own location.

*** *** 

Please share via social media below.

Advertisements

5 replies »

  1. I am not a witness yet did study. My wife and children serve as Jehovah’s witnesses and I found your article thought provocative as I did not consider it in those terms. I am conflicted though as it brings them joy and they are doing so motivated by love. I do see the conflict if the motive is as malicious as one designed to leverage cheap labour. From my experience I have seen that it is a loving arrangement – and if the malice is determined from cause it would likely be found under whom stands to profit based on your argument.
    I used to help my dad build our garage and with woodwork as a young child, that too brings into question motive – somewhere if good comes from our actions we too should not discount the dignity afforded to children as much as those who are old and infirm too – we all wish to express love and cherish our labours to improve on yesterday and should be supported, encouraged and appreciated for our contribution. My mother who was a quadriplegic patient for much of her life taught me such. In order for me to afford her dignity, I was to allow and support her to still be my mother and illustrate I still value her albeit she may yet fail. In the end she mentored many, supported herself through mouth painting and poetry, skills she needed to learn – to which she again felt she could add value – do not deny people their freedom. Profiteering from such benevolence though robs dignity. It poses an interesting question in such regard. Who stands to profit?

  2. I agree with your blog entirely. I was a child growing up in the JW cult, I was forced to go out preaching every Saturday and Sunday all day except for I when The meetings were taking place. I hated it, it was embarrassing, tiring and stressful. The meetings were taking place. I hated it, it was embarrassing, tiring and stressful. It interfered with my homework, I had no time at all to be myself It interfered with my homework, I had no time at all to be myself or just to simply recuperate over the weekend. I think one thing that your blog doesn’t mention but also is an important point is that JW children also have to to go to many meetings a week, on the evenings when they’re not at meetings they have to study and prepare for the next one, they still have to do the daily text every morning and it is completely overwhelming. No child should be forced into this life of constant servitude. And we were forced. We couldn’t opt out even when we were ill or exhausted. It’s a complete travesty.

  3. This was worked out in the courts many years ago. They work with their parents in do things apporpriate to their age in praise to Jehovah;.l

    • Except that this isn’t a court of law; as I point out, it’s my blog, and what is legal is not always loving or even decent. Shunning your own family is sickening and obscene, but also legal. Their work is also not in praise to anyone but their organization; they make money for the governing body, not for the poor in other countries or any type of social or charitable work. If anything, the work they make their children do simply proves that they are anything but a loving religion that cares about children.

  4. Reblogged this on Thoughts on Life and commented:
    I remember volunteering at the assemblies as a young child of about 11 or 12 working in food, way back when they sold breakfasts and lunches. It was my introduction to food service. At least I followed the laws and used the gloves and hairnets. Why is this pictured child without protective gear on a construction site?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s