Are Jehovah's Witnesses a Cult?

In Stunning Video Release, Jehovah’s Witnesses Encourage Struggling Father to Give Up Job Opportunity for the Religion

Videos from the 2016 summer regional conventions of Jehovah’s Witnesses are being revealed online, and they are nothing short of brutal. In one stunning, jaw-dropping account, an obviously struggling father is lauded for giving up a job opportunity in exchange for more time spent adhering to the demands of the religion:

Commanded to Provide, Not Just Study

Interesting to note that the man’s employer already gives him time to attend the meetings of Jehovah’s Witnesses, so what is this man missing, or would he be missing, from taking this new opportunity? At the end of the video, the man’s little girl talks about their family study that evening. This is disturbing; the man would give up a job opportunity just for family study time, especially considering how economically depressed his family is, given the small and humble home of theirs?

Yes, the bible says to teach your children and instruct them, but it doesn’t say when or on what schedule. The man couldn’t come home an hour later each evening and still instruct his child? The mother couldn’t pitch in and study with the children as needed? This structured, scheduled family study is something that was created by Jehovah’s Witnesses and pushed even more when they went from two weekly meetings at their Kingdom Halls to just one; they then said that the other evening should be used for a “family worship” night. Again, this was their idea, their instructions, and not something commanded in the bible.

Note too that the bible does command that a person provide for his (or her) own household:

Certainly if anyone does not provide for those who are his own, and especially for those who are members of his household, he has disowned the faith and is worse than a person without faith.
~ 1 Timothy 5:8

The bible doesn’t say that you need to provide a comfortable lifestyle for your household, but you are obligated to work and put food on the table, and in today’s tough economies and shrinking job market, that can mean exercising some discretion so you don’t put a job at risk. The video isn’t clear as to what would happen to this man if he were to refuse this job opportunity, but many of us know that refusing any assignment from your boss can make them angry enough to get rid of you altogether. To turn down an assignment, promotion, transfer, etc., simply for the sake of being home an hour earlier so you can immerse yourself and your family in more religious indoctrination seems risky; again, the point being, this is the religion telling him to spend that time indoctrinating his children, not the bible telling him that.

The gross hypocrisy in this is worth mentioning; the governing body of Jehovah’s Witnesses don’t work to provide for themselves or their families. They are supported by the religion. The religion itself also practices no official charitable works, so if that man and his family were out on the streets because of his decision, it’s not like they could visit the soup line set up at the local Kingdom Hall. Yet, the religion is all too happy to risk his livelihood, his means of support, when they’re not the ones who would need to suffer the consequences of his decision.

Outside, Looking In

Jehovah’s Witnesses are rarely concerned with how their behavior, religious beliefs, and needs affect other people; for one thing, people “in the world,” or those who are not Jehovah’s Witnesses, are pretty much dead to them. Jehovah’s Witnesses believe that any day now, any minute now, Armageddon is coming and all those people, including their bosses, are going to die. Why worry about their opinions then, since their lives are so immaterial?

armageddon-watchtower-sep-15-2012

Why care what your employer needs when you expect them to die a horrible, fiery death, any day now?

Another reason they aren’t much concerned is that their religion comes first, above all else. I can respect this to a certain extent; in my own personal life, I wouldn’t allow someone to tell me that I need to give up an opinion, friend, spiritual pursuit, hobby, and so on.

However, Jehovah’s Witnesses often forget that other people, especially employers, are constantly accommodating them and their beliefs. A Witness employee will insist that they be given time off for their summer conventions, or will refuse to put up signs advertising a Christmas sale or sell cigarettes when working a cash register. If an employer hesitates to accommodate these things, they can be accused of religious discrimination.

A JW employee in a hospital or medical setting might even reveal confidential medical information to elders if they see a JW patient doing anything they deem questionable, such as taking blood, terminating a pregnancy, and so on. Consider these huge legal issues for an employer when it comes to confidentiality and their liability, and in just trying to run a business. Yet, Jehovah’s Witnesses often act as if the employers are creating such a terrible situation for them by simply asking them to do their jobs, which brings me to my next point.

Oh, the Persecution!

What is also bothersome but becoming too common with these videos produced by Jehovah’s Witnesses is the misapplication of scripture for the man’s situation, and their hysteria and dramatics. When contemplating his decision, the man reads Romans 8:36-37:

36 Just as it is written: “For your sake we are being put to death all day long; we have been accounted as sheep for slaughtering.” 37 On the contrary, in all these things we are coming off completely victorious through the one who loved us.

How exactly was this man being “slaughtered” or “put to death,” even figuratively? His employer states that he gives him time off for his meetings, so his schedule and his religion are being accommodated. The man isn’t facing a prison sentence or concentration camp; he just needs to think about a job opportunity with a longer commute.

Here too Jehovah’s Witnesses are playing up any and all outside influences or life away from their religion as persecution and a problem that doesn’t actually exist. The mere thought that someone might need to curtail the time spent with the religion’s indoctrination – not miss it altogether, mind you, but just curtail it – is considered a living death and spiritual slaughtering. I would assume this is part of their methods of controlling their members; don’t dare step away from the religion and its incessant teaching, indoctrination, inculcation, etc., because then you might not want to step back.

*** ***

Please share via social media below.

Advertisements

4 replies »

  1. Been there!!! My ex-husband left a good job to be a better elder, to do more for the congregation, and to do a menial job making tens of thousands of dollars less a year. Of course as a submissive and regular pioneering wife, I thought it was a great idea too. How delusional we were!! But at the flip side, I am what I am today; which is an ex- Jehovah’s Witness with a master’s degree.

  2. Wives know only too well that the ideal is often not the reality. Some husbands, when faced with financial pressure, withdraw and become depressed, and a scenario like this would exert further pressure on a male, pressed in all directions. That does not make for a happy home environment.

    So many muster up what little energy reserves they have left to put on their suit and happy face when going to the meetings but once they are back home behind closed doors, it’s a different story. Then the real picture emerges: tension, arguing, drinking, withdrawal, marital breakdown.

    In our old congregation, almost all were on anti-depressants or had Fibromyalgia or CFS or mystery illnesses.

  3. I remember hearing, the wife of one of the congregation elders telling my mother that her husband had been offered a good promotion. He was a U.S. mail carrier; they had four children, she was a full time housewife and they rented a two bedroom 800 square foot house. She proudly told my mother how she reminded her husband that soon Armageddon would come, ushering in the “new system of things.” She encouraged him to stay focused on serving god, not his employment. He turned down the promotion and, with his wife, waited it out for the “new system of things.” That was over 40 years ago.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s